Balor with attacks to Sheamus and Rollins before Gargano super kicks him.

Source: https://411mania.com/wrestling/wwe-royal-rumble-review-2023-winfree/

Gargano allowed his previous WWE contract to expire in late 2021.

Source: https://comicbook.com/wwe/news/wwe-johnny-gargano-shoulder-injury-surgery-update/

Gargano couldn't pick up the win in his return to his old stomping grounds.

Source: https://www.cagesideseats.com/2023/12/3/23986228/tag-team-weekly-roundup-and-power-ratings-will-the-rise-of-diamond

Grimes hit Lee and Gargano with a double Frankendriver.

Source: https://prowrestling.net/site/2023/11/28/nxt-tv-results-11-28-moores-review-of-tony-dangelo-and-channing-lorenzo-vs-angel-garza-and-humberto-carrillo-for-the-nxt-tag-team-titles-iron-survivor-challenge-qualifiers/

Haskins also discussed where British wrestling stands in 2023, Progress Wrestling, Johnny Gargano, and more.

Source: https://prowrestling.net/site/2023/08/23/mark-haskins-on-working-with-kenta-during-defys-uk-debut-feels-he-has-unfinished-business-in-roh-his-desire-to-wrestle-wwes-butch-pete-dunne-again/

I don’t want to see a mixed tag team feud with Gargano and Candice LeRae against Lumis and Cross, but at least Gargano would be done playing sidekick to the babyface serial killer.

Source: https://prowrestling.net/site/2023/02/07/powells-wwe-raw-hit-list-cody-rhodes-and-paul-heyman-becky-lynch-vs-bayley-in-a-cage-match-brock-lesnar-and-bobby-lashley-michin-vs-candice-lerae-vs-piper-niven-vs-carmella-in-a-four-way-in/

I don’t want to see a mixed tag team feud with Gargano and Candice LeRae against Lumis and Cross, but at least Gargano would be done playing sidekick to the babyface serial killer.

Source: https://prowrestling.net/site/2023/02/07/powells-wwe-raw-hit-list-cody-rhodes-and-paul-heyman-becky-lynch-vs-bayley-in-a-cage-match-brock-lesnar-and-bobby-lashley-michin-vs-candice-lerae-vs-piper-niven-vs-carmella-in-a-four-way-in/

Johnny Gargano and Seth Rollins started the match.

Source: https://prowrestling.net/site/2023/02/18/wwe-elimination-chamber-results-powells-live-review-of-roman-reigns-vs-sami-zayn-for-the-undisputed-wwe-universal-championship-brock-lesnar-vs-bobby-lashley-two-elimination-chamber-matches-edg/

Johnny Gargano wins by submission with the Gargano Escape.

Source: https://www.cagesideseats.com/wwe/2023/4/1/23659501/wwe-nxt-stand-deliver-2023-live-streaming-match-results-coverage

Johnny Gargano wins by submission with the Gargano Escape.

Source: https://www.cagesideseats.com/wwe/2023/4/1/23659501/wwe-nxt-stand-deliver-2023-live-streaming-match-results-coverage

On the January 30 episode of Seth Rollins and Johnny Gargano also qualified for the titular match.

Source: https://screenrant.com/bronson-reed-wwe-elimination-chamber-united-states-championship/

Otis drops Gargano face-first into the announce desk and flexes for Maxxine Dupri!

Source: https://www.cagesideseats.com/wwe/2023/2/27/23616117/wwe-raw-results-live-blog-feb-27-2023-tag-team-title-match-damage-ctrl-vs-becky-lynch-lita

Otis with Maximum Male Models actually sounds a lot more fun than Gargano actually has been since Dexter Lumis showed up.

Source: https://prowrestling.net/site/2023/02/27/2-27-wwe-raw-results-powells-live-review-of-dakota-kai-and-iyo-sky-vs-becky-lynch-and-lita-for-the-wwe-womens-tag-team-titles-brock-lesnar-responds-to-omoss-wm39-challenge-cody-rhodes-vs-ch/

Uppercut from the Sicilian Psychopath, whip reversed, big chop, jawbreaker, Gargano tags in and they lay Tozawa out with a double-team!

Source: https://www.cagesideseats.com/wwe/2023/11/27/23976971/wwe-raw-results-live-blog-nov-27-2023-cm-punk-returns-randy-orton-survivor-series-fallout